The Busiest Supreme Court In The Land

  • Law

My what a busy Supreme Court Nevada has! Yesterday, they churned out what must have surely been a record number of opinions and even introduced the beta version of their new website. We have a few of the highlights after the jump:

  • The Court ruled against 8th Judicial District Court Judge Doug Smith who tried to collect retirement from his prior service with the county as a public defender, prosecutor, and justice of the peace by “retiring.” The article points out that Justice Hardesty chastised a lawyer during oral argument who was suggesting Smith was trying to double dip, saying there was nothing sinister about his actions and if he would have collected retirement had he filled out the paperwork correctly. Rumor has it Smith will be collecting that retirement soon enough. [RJ; Opinion-Nev. Pub. Emps. Bd. v. Smith]
  • Speaking of Judge Smith, a man’s rape conviction was overturned because Smith did not give adequate consideration to the jury composition–just 2 of the 65 jurors were the same race as the defendant. [RJ]
  • It’s a tale as old as time. Two women fall in love, have a child by fertilizing the one woman’s egg and implanting in the other woman to carry and birth the child, and then have a falling out and can’t decide who is the mother. So, the question was which one is the mother–the woman’s whose egg was fertilized or the “surrogate” who carried the child and actually gave birth. It’s kind of a trick question and this is one where you really need to read the opinion to get the full effect, but basically the Court says that there is nothing that says a child can’t have two mothers. The case was remanded to the lower court to make a finding of fact with that in mind. [RJ; Opinion-St. Mary v. Damon]
  • The Court followed the recommendation of the Disciplinary Board and disbarred Ronald Serota for misappropriation of client funds. If we’ve said it once, we’ve said it a million times: don’t mess with your client’s money! [RJ; Opinion-In re Discipline of Serota]
  • The Court clarified that steel inspectors qualify as design professionals and suits brought against them without the appropriate certificates of merit are void ab initio. [Opinion-In re CityCenter]
  • Nevada’s UCC allows revocation of acceptance of delivery made to a manufacturer when the manufacturer sufficiently inserts themselves into the sales process. [Opinion-Newmar Corp. v. McCrary]
  • The other half of the advance opinions issued yesterday can be viewed here. 
Also, there is one other story that should be on your radar. The I-Team from 8NewsNow is reporting that a former Metro officer who was using his badge and uniform to sexually harass women was released from prison back in March after serving only two months of a two year sentence. Metro says he was offered house arrest based on his record and received no special treatment, is registered as a sex offender, wears an ankle monitor, and has to check in once a month. As expected, his victims are outraged.
1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
October 4, 2013 8:19 pm

THat's messed up that Hardesty was sticking up for Smith.