Luge

  • Law

  • City and county attorneys struggling with the dilemma of advising their clients on how to set up medical marijuana dispensaries are seeking a change in the Rules of Professional Conduct Rule 1.2 so they can give advice on act that is criminal under federal law. [RJ]
  • The Clark County Detention Center begins a four year renovation project on March 1. [RJ]
  • Attorney General candidate Adam Laxalt says he would defend Nevada’s ban on same-sex marriage. His opponent Ross Miller supports the actions current AG Catherine Cortez-Masto. [Las Vegas Sun]
  • United States Attorney General Eric Holder wants Nevada and 10 other states to restore voting rights to ex-felons. [RJ]
22 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 12, 2014 6:33 pm

When I first saw that article called "NV attorneys call for rule change on medical pot issue" I thought it was going to be asking for a rule that permits them to use it.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 13, 2014 1:40 am
Reply to  Anonymous

Did someone say we couldn't????

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 12, 2014 7:17 pm

I know that the tide has turned, and it is now super-uncool to be anti-gay marriage, but I am confused as to how the AG thinks she has the right to not defend a constitutional amendment. Her oath specifically says she will "support, protect and defend the constitution and government of the State of Nevada." It does not say that she gets to choose which parts of the constitution she gets to defend based upon her own political views.

I will be voting for Laxalt – not because he is anti-gay marriage, but because I want an AG that will defend the State Constitution, especially items that have been passed by the voters. If the constitutional provision is abhorrent or out-of-touch will today's standards and mores, then the place to change that is through the legislative/electoral process – not through the AG's refusal to defend.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 12, 2014 7:38 pm
Reply to  Anonymous

Maybe she had Rule 11 issues?

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 12, 2014 7:45 pm
Reply to  Anonymous

She originally filed the amicus brief to carry out that duty. The brief was based on the theory that sexual orientation is not a suspect class for equal protection purposes. The opinion from the Ninth issued on the same day as the State filed the brief blew that argument out of the water. So at least in front of the Ninth, she couldn't let the brief stand.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 12, 2014 7:48 pm
Reply to  Anonymous

oh, conlaw. My head hurts…

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 12, 2014 10:08 pm
Reply to  Anonymous

@11:45. But she can still defend under heightened scrutiny and could try to distinguish the juror case or argue it is not precedential in her case. She wants an excuse to bail for political reasons.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 12, 2014 10:54 pm
Reply to  Anonymous

You are incredibly naive if you think the AG (of a state or of the US) does not make decisions based on politics. It happens every day. Moreover, while I am certainly not a fan of Masto, in this case she actually made a stand-up decision. Should all the AGs of southern states refused to enforce civil rights because the majority of the state's citizens wanted to continue to discriminate? That is just one example.

The AG takes an oath to "support, protect and defend the constitution and government of the United States, and the constitution and government of the State of Nevada, against all enemies, whether domestic or foreign, and [swears that she] will bear true faith, allegiance and loyalty to the same, any ordinance, resolution or law of any state notwithstanding." In other words, the AG is sworn to protect basic constitutional rights first and foremost, regardless of some bone-headed "law".

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 12, 2014 11:52 pm
Reply to  Anonymous

Hmm, I don't remember much Con Law, but I am pretty sure there is a difference between, say, the NAC or some other "bone headed" law and a duly enacted amendment to the Nevada Constitution.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 13, 2014 4:53 pm
Reply to  Anonymous

It is a bone headed law even if in the state constitution if it violates the US constitution. You are right, you don't remember much con law.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 12, 2014 8:02 pm

Well, I for one want an AG who is willing ignore common sense and common decency, and expend state resources by rowing his office's boat against the tide of history, in a Quixotic attempt to keep bigoted and valueless referendums on the books.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 12, 2014 9:24 pm
Reply to  Anonymous

I'll vote for that guy!!!

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 12, 2014 10:27 pm
Reply to  Anonymous

Sure, let's have the AG be like a vice-governor, making policy as he goes. That's exactly what we want the top law enforcement official in the state doing. Well-reasoned.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 13, 2014 12:00 am
Reply to  Anonymous

Not to get too technical here, but it's no longer a "valueless referendum" if it has been voted upon and enacted as an amendment to the Nevada Constitution, right? If the AG's duty is to defend the Nevada Constitution, that's what the AG must do.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 13, 2014 12:32 am
Reply to  Anonymous

Oh, good God. Did you miss the day when they talked about the Supremacy Clause? When they went over how the provisions in the Bill of Rights dealing with fundamental rights were incorporated by the Due Process clause of the 14th Amendment? US Constitution > State Constitution. Every time. So if a clause in the State Constitution violates the US Constitution, and the AG's role is to uphold the Constitution of the US, that means he/she has to forego enforcing unconstitutional provisions in the state constitution. In this case, I may not agree with the AG's position, but I can certainly understand it, especially given the State's chief executive's acquiescence. The question before the Ninth Circuit is now 1) Does Baker still preclude an EP challenge, and 2) What would Judge Jones have ruled if required to use heightened scrutiny? If the answer to 1 is "No," they remand back to Jones for further analysis in light of SmithKline. If the answer to 1 is "Yes," they affirm the lower court's ruling.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 13, 2014 4:48 am
Reply to  Anonymous

Thank you @ 4:32. You saved me the chore of pointing out to the folks who say "I don't care about gay marriage, but the AG has a duty to defend it" conveniently forget about the US Constitution. Of course that person is against gay marriage. With the DOMA decision and several others, the writing is on the wall.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 13, 2014 2:54 am

4:32 – thank you thank you thank you. Maybe 11:17 can become a Fox News pundit, where you can espouse opinions while ignoring facts.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 13, 2014 4:19 pm

11:17 here – that sounds like a great career option rather than doing what I am doing now. BTW, I never saw a right to gay marriage in the U.S. Constitution either … just saying.

But, the real point of my original comment was that I want an AG that defends the Nevada Constitution, whether it is popular or not.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 13, 2014 4:52 pm
Reply to  Anonymous

Really? If it wasn't specifically enumerated by long dead slave holders, there is no "right." Scary to think you are a lawyer … just sayin.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 13, 2014 4:56 pm
Reply to  Anonymous

It's not a matter of "popular" — it's a matter of whether there is a tenable position to argue this FEDERALLY unconstitutional law should be upheld.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 13, 2014 6:03 pm
Reply to  Anonymous

4:32 here. When you file a brief arguing the constitutionality of a law based on rational basis standard of review, and the controlling circuit then comes out and decides the applicable standard is heightened scrutiny, what do you do? Do you continue to argue the point in direct contravention of controlling authority? No. You withdraw the damn brief, unless you can find some strongly persuasive way of distinguishing it. Are you seriously trying to say she should continue to fight the good fight and ignore adverse controlling authority? That's ethical violation territory.

8:52: Methinks you and I have fundamental disagreements on what the Bill of Rights actually did. It didn't specifically enumerate jack. It specifically prohibited the federal government from taking actions against a particular group of rights. Those rights existed before they were mentioned in the BoR, and existed afterwards, because they were never granted by the Constitution. The people already had them, the problem was getting the government to respect that. To the extent that an activity falls under the definition of those rights, it also prohibits federal government from taking actions against it. Penumbra isn't a dirty word.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
February 14, 2014 10:49 pm

11:17 here – I am a complete dumbass and should cease to practice law immediately. Thank you.